I wasn't aware that the first sentence wasn't enough to give the impression that you can't just generate infinite chunks. And you'll need infinite chunks.
Non-renewable Items?
- Thread starter jumpfight5
- Start date
-
The FTB Forum is now read-only, and is here as an archive. To participate in our community discussions, please join our Discord! https://ftb.team/discord
There seems to be a confusion between pseudo-infinite (or even infinite) and renewable.
And even with Mystcraft, you do not have infinite chunks, you just multiply the amount by a huge number (Mystcraft worlds are limited in number).
Anyway, infinite does not equals renewable anyway.
Renewable means that you can actively create an item/block through a process that only consumes other renewable items, and in a manner that the loop creates new items and can be repeated indefinitely.
Would be nice to finally have a recipe for cobwebs though...
And even with Mystcraft, you do not have infinite chunks, you just multiply the amount by a huge number (Mystcraft worlds are limited in number).
Anyway, infinite does not equals renewable anyway.
Renewable means that you can actively create an item/block through a process that only consumes other renewable items, and in a manner that the loop creates new items and can be repeated indefinitely.
Would be nice to finally have a recipe for cobwebs though...
Yes that's not the point, the point is, they are not renewable. You can't create them, nor do they regenerate nor are they spawned by anything, you have to find them naturally in the world. And the world including Mystcraft isn't infinite, it is just very very very very very very very very big.
There is a mod that adds elite versions of mobs, which can have "web throwing" ability but that mod isn't in the packs.
Speaking about this, you raise a very valid point: Saddles.
As far as I know, there is no way to craft them, right?
As far as I know, there is no way to craft them, right?
nope, so I guess they ain't renewable
and in my opinion, they shouldn't be craftable, just like cobwebs.
You can obtain them, but not infinitely (vanilla speaking)
Oh, I did not know that. But saddles should have a crafting recipe. Okay Steve, you can make a house out of your bare hands and kill dragons, but you can't put a couple of pieces of leather, some string, and an iron together?
hey steve, you can kill a dragon, why can't you steal the bow of that skeleton you just killed? why don't you steall all the gold armor of that zombie and melt it back to ingots? why don't you enchant a stick?
because sometimes doesn't make sense, and sometimes mojang doesn't want. Oh, and this is a sandbox, you don't necessarily need to kill a dragon/make a house (like I do, never build a house, and killed the dragon after 2 hours of gameplay)
Just add one of the many mods that add recipe for saddle. I found 5 during 5 minutes with google.
I can see the armor/weapons disintegrating with the un-dead. But, yeah. According to the achievements, you need leather before you can get the Saddle achievement, so it looks like it will be added...eventually?[DOUBLEPOST=1364086350][/DOUBLEPOST]
Yeah, but it's not part of the mod pack. A lot of mods add them, especially mods that add mobs.
at minecon some kid asked how much time it would take him (Jeb) to implement a saddle recipe (answer = 3 seconds) but he said he didn't want to, because is more like an achievement for when you find dungeons (like, who crafts disks? come on, kill creepers with skeletons)
And why such mod should be a part of modpack? Is there any mod that require saddles in FTB and would it add any value except as an replacement for exploring and satisfying weird need for renewability not involving villagers?
I remember I made a setup where there were 3 holes, one for a skeleton, creeper, and me. Then I just got them both into their holes and the skeleton shot the creeper and I got a disk.
Do Soul Shard skeletons have the ability to get Soul Shard creepers to drop discs?
....no, the only mods that needed saddles that I know of is Atmos, MoCreatures, and the Aether (I think).
And what's wrong with the satisfaction of my weird needs?
Ah, yes, now I remember. Stuff you renew from Villagers. Saddles, for instance. No way to automate trading AFAIK.
I think the player should count. To get infinite discs, you'll need to have a player standing behind a creeper and a skeleton to get them. You can't really do it any other way (unless you got two skeletons to attack eachother and get creepers caught in cross fire, but that probably wouldn't work all too well).
But I say the player should count.
But I say the player should count.