Beginner's Quest - First Time Being a GM! [GAME THREAD]

[Pyure]

Unofficial Recap. If you didn't bold your vote, I may have missed it. I caught Lethosos's vote. Up to RealKC if he wants to count it.


Nojr (2): Lethosos, Fowltief
SomeoneElse (4) Fred, Ulfari, Shazam08, Pyure
LivingAngryCheese (2) SomeoneElse37, Nojr
Pyure (1) Robijn
Failed: @LivingAngryCheese (For some reason?), @CorpseCat

 

[RealKC]

RECAP COMING!

 

[Pyure]

Real, just to stop us from sniping each other, you should probably append "DAY IS OVER" to your recap messages.

Otherwise I'm going to point out to Shazam08 how suspicious his last 9* messages were.

*Yes he has more than 9 posts if you don't restrict yourself to this thread. Suspicious, right?

 

[RealKC]

DAY IS OVER!Are you happy now Pyure?

he town decided to lynch SO37, he was a Person!
The bad guys executed CorpseCat, (s)he was a Person!

@LivingAngryCheese has lost his first grace smite!

(Consider the period I do the PM stuff and update the OP from now on in my games a very short night)

 

[RealKC]

D3 has started!

@Lethosos make your votes bold from now on, ok? I always just type the BBCode myself, it's not hard.
@LivingAngryCheese try to vote people

 

[Robijnvogel]

I meant to post this over half an hour ago, but since Fred voted for SE as well, I guess it wouldn't have mattered.

To paraphrase Real from the previous game: "Never trust Pyure."

##vote Cheese

Pyure, Shaz/Fowl and Cheese wolf-team?

 

[Pyure]

Rob, fwiw, I still have you as most-likely-town, although I'm not feeling great about this whole "things didn't go perfectly last night, let's kill whoever tried their hardest" tone.

Cheese is def. town.

 

[fowltief]

see why i didn't hop on? Now lets go after the real bad guy

Vote Fred

He is definitely hiding something I know of it.

i'll keep robbie on netural for now.

 

[Pyure]

@fowltief: your whole post screams wolf.

I can't go after fred OR rob. Both of them have been avoiding bandwagons and failing to drop wolf tells.

I missed on SE37, but I'll take 2/3 as a decent wolfhunt stat and be happy with it. Vote fowltief.

 

[Pyure]

@Shazam08, I feel like you've been real quiet this game for town!shazam. It makes me nervous. Talk to me about fowltief and how good an idea it is to lynch him.

 

[Pyure]

@LivingAngryCheese: *I* know you're town, but these plebes don't. Talk to them about how dumb an idea it is to lynch you.

 

[Robijnvogel]

@Pyure
Not really... you tried the hardest yesterday, so if you were town, you'd be the greatest threat to the wolves regardless of having been wrong or not yesterday.
So please tell me your explanation of why the wolves killed CC instead of you.

On top of that, SE's call on you calling Cheese towny, was totally justified. Your statement came out of the blue and was based on air.

Not changing my vote. If you want me to, hand me something solid.

 

[fowltief]

@Shazam08, I feel like you've been real quiet this game for town!shazam. It makes me nervous. Talk to me about fowltief and how good an idea it is to lynch him.

do you honestly think i'd make it so obvious that i'm a wolf?

 

[Lethosos]

I'm still pointing at Nojr for now.

##Vote Nojr

Sent from my Puzzle Box of Yogg-Saron using Tapatalk 2

 

[Pyure]

@Pyure
Not really... you tried the hardest yesterday, so if you were town, you'd be the greatest threat to the wolves regardless of having been wrong or not yesterday.
So please tell me your explanation of why the wolves killed CC instead of you.

That's easy. Why the hell would they kill someone who is pushing to lynch Se37, who was town? If I had hit two wolves in a row, different story, but so long as I'm inadvertently doing their dirty work, killing me is extremely stupid.

On top of that, SE's call on you calling Cheese towny, was totally justified. Your statement came out of the blue and was based on air.

Not changing my vote. If you want me to, hand me something solid.

I know Cheese is town due to private convos. That's legit in this game. Peeps gotta tolerate it.

 

[Robijnvogel]

That's easy. Why the hell would they kill someone who is pushing to lynch Se37, who was town? If I had hit two wolves in a row, different story, but so long as I'm inadvertently doing their dirty work, killing me is extremely stupid.

If the wolves didn't try to kill you, they obviously don't consider you a threat...
So why should we listen to you?

I know Cheese is town due to private convos. That's legit in this game. Peeps gotta tolerate it.

Or you are lying, because you are both wolves... I don't see how this is a relevant argument.

 

[Pyure]

If the wolves didn't try to kill you, they obviously don't consider you a threat...
So why should we listen to you?

Well, if you are absolutely terrible at mafia, or are a wolf, or don't care that I KILLED A WOLF ON D1, maybe you shouldn't?

Or you are lying, because you are both wolves... I don't see how this is a relevant argument.

We can argue about game of thrones instead if you don't want to have an argument related to finding scum.

 

[Robijnvogel]

I will give a scenario description of my Pyure, Shaz, Cheese and Erin wolf pack hypothesis before the end of this day.

Sent from my HUAWEI G750-U10 using Tapatalk

 

[fowltief]

Well, if you are absolutely terrible at mafia, or are a wolf, or don't care that I KILLED A WOLF ON D1, maybe you shouldn't?
We can argue about game of thrones instead if you don't want to have an argument related to finding scum.

Cheese is inno. Guaranteed. Yes his vote was dumb. Yes there's a remote outside chance I'm wrong on this. No I'm not wrong on this.

Lynch Someone Else 37 the megawolf.

You got lucky. like you said a rare event. finding scum with little to no info on day one is no easy task. Still doesn't clear you in my opinion. if it was 2 for 2 then yes even i would listen to you too. But that is not the case. I took my vote off after his speech as i really didn't have anything tying him down.

that being said i have nothing against you either, your trying very hard. I don't know why. But i do know this....

Lock Vote Fred Guaranteed. Think of it what you will.

 

[LivingAngryCheese]

Thanks for the tip on Shaz robjn. Pretty sure he's town now that you put him in the list of possible wolves. You see, just because SE flipped inno, doesn't mean that I'm a wolf. That IS how wolf SE usually plays. If you kill me, WE LOSE. ALREADY. But I bet you already know that don't you? You're a wolf I bet. Pyure got a wolf killed D1. You have contributed nothing to us villagers. I accept that pyure may be exploiting my weakness to make him look town, but even with the insane amount of wolves, I doubt that he'd sacrifice someone D1. It's perfectly possible. Close to 50% of living players are wolves right now. After all of this, the one player that has done something useful so far is wrong? Really? Let's just go for fowl here, it's an almost guaranteed wolf kill and we'll have more information to work with. vote fowl