Recently finally made an account, so I figured I'd comment on a few modpacks I've been playing recently.
This pack is a strange one. I don't think it's for me in the end. The inventory thing and the unskippable darkness in a peaceful pack is a bit too much in the vein of annoyance in place of challenge. I don't like being annoyed.
I did have a rather... unique introduction to the pack too. I tried it when it just came out, and nobody was talking about the...issues with minetweaker yet.
First go, I create a world, jump in, and spawn on a platform near an island at sea. It's pitch black. And mobs are
everywhere. 'B-but this is supposed to be a peaceful pack? Maybe only RFTools dimensions have monsters?' and there's other parts to the mod? Welp, I eventually wade ashore at the mainland, blindly. And survive until day somehow. I quickly put together some basic tools and a small house and find some sheep to make a bed to avoid those stupidly dark nights, thank heavens.
Boom. Everything gone. And on fire. Much frowning and weeping.
Restart.
Peaceful mode! Huzzah! Still annoying dark. But I get some basic farms up and do some branch mining in a caveless world. But I get to the quest to make return trip machines, as, like, the second quest. After much super-exciting walking up and down stairs to ferry mined metals I get the resources and redstone and such, getting a smeltery going. But I need ender pearls for one of the dimensional thingers. In a peaceful pack. With no seemingly special way go get ender pearls. With no direction. 'Wow,' I thought, 'I expected way more out of these modpack makers than these useless sparing quests.' Eventually I cobble together a philosopher's stone, using the glowstone from the warp-in platform and make an ender pearl that way. And thankfully I had just enough for it. And hey, since I have like two dozen dimensional shards worth half a million each from casual small-scale mining at y=10, why not use them? Cue power flower.
Welp, I win minecraft. In my first mining run I found loads of platinum and now have stuff better than grape-flavored tools with next to none of the difficulty. I have a gateway to essentially creative mode with ProjectE's power flowers. Now what?
Quit.
The next day I poke and prod in the forums and find out it was a minetweaker fail, and give it another go!
Ahh, much more sense. Wood! Who knew that you could make futuristic interdimensional teleporters out of slabs and planks of oak wood? The scientists are going to be
so embarrassed when they realize simple carpentry you can do in your garage is the secret to instantaneous transportation between worlds. Still annoyingly dark, which would be an awesome and scary mod in a horror or combat pack, but the danger of tripping and falling into a shallow pit is not exactly nervewracking. Still annoying to cart things around. Couldn't I just mess around with RFTools in another pack without being irritated by having no inventory? It's nice as a tutorial to the mod. And the quests are super-clear and great that way. Some of the best I've seen, once they make sense with minetweaker working. But... I could watch a video too, much more quickly.
Quit.
I'm sure the pack will have its fans. I just really don't think I'm one of 'em. Maybe it has some interesting perk over a kitchen sink pack with RFTools set to peaceful that I'm not seeing, to offset being a pain, but it didn't show it to me or hint that it was there. So I think I'll take a pass on this one. Good luck with the pack!