1. Please make sure you are posting in the correct place. Server ads go here and modpack bugs go here

Smelting stuff fast, a comparison =)

Discussion in 'General FTB chat' started by belgabor, Jun 7, 2014.

  1. Dezz

    Dezz Well-Known Member

    Any suggested engines that heat it up to that point? Other than the magnetostatic, cause magnetizing those things is a pain, even if you can do it 16 at a time.

    Edit: If I remember correctly, penulitmate means one before last
     
  2. belgabor

    belgabor New Member

    Yes. You need 33MW (rounded, actually it's whatever power of 2 is next to that)
     
    Dezz likes this.
  3. malicious_bloke

    malicious_bloke Over-Achiever

    Well, a gas turbine outputs a ton of power, if you want to break it down to a manageable level for the friction heater, just use a shaft junction and split it 1:7, feed the rest of the power into something else that wont kersplode if you over-rev it :)
     
    Dezz likes this.
  4. belgabor

    belgabor New Member

    That could actually be too much. 3:1 seems to hit it quite close
     
    Dezz likes this.
  5. Dezz

    Dezz Well-Known Member

    If it needs 33MW and a Gas Turbine outputs about 67MW, a 2:1 might work, perhaps?
     
  6. Pyure

    Pyure Not Totally Useless

    The friction heater is a bit of an oddball.

    I wish I could remember where, because someone posted precise numbers a couple weeks ago. But basically it boils down to the friction heater wanting more or less equal speed/torque (rather than pure power: 16MW from pure torque or speed won't create any appreciable heat)

    At 4096x4096 (16MW) you cook a stack in ~9s.

    A decent number seems to be 6144x6144 (for 37MW). At this speed it heats up to around 1930C and bakes a stack in ~6s.

    Getting the heater up to 1998C doesn't cook it any faster (7168x7168).

    This might not be as fast as some other means, but its worth noting that both the friction heater (and furnace obviously) are, relatively speaking, rather simple and cheap to build. (Powering it is another matter)
     
  7. Dezz

    Dezz Well-Known Member

    Gas Turbines are easier to get than you might think, or easier to fuel up I guess.

    Fractionation Units are rather easy to power.

    It's getting those tungsten flakes that piss me off lol
     
  8. TheAwesomater

    TheAwesomater New Member

    So 32768 I'm guessing?
     
  9. malicious_bloke

    malicious_bloke Over-Achiever

    Silk touch enchanted quarrying machine of any sort will net you a metric ton of redstone ore. Simples ;)
     
  10. belgabor

    belgabor New Member

    NO! That sounds like you think of a a gearbox. A gearbox doesn't change the power, only how it's distributed on torque/speed. With a gearbox, depending on how the ratio impacts on the heat produced (as @Pyure said) you might well still be in kaboom range.
    not quite, the power is based on Watts and I rounded to SI Mega Watts. It's 33554432 Watts. (Which apparently means I cannot round properly -.-)
     
    Last edited: Jun 14, 2014
    Pyure likes this.
  11. malicious_bloke

    malicious_bloke Over-Achiever

    As belbagor said, the total power running through a gearbox is unchanged by the multiplier to torque or speed.

    A 2:1 split of 67MW on a shaft junction would approximate to 44.7 one way and 22.3 the other, so you go over or under either way.

    Shaft junctions split the total (or add them together in the other mode), they don't act as a multiplier
     
  12. belgabor

    belgabor New Member

    But a shaft junction cannot split 2:1 :)
     
  13. Dezz

    Dezz Well-Known Member

    I'm quite aware of what a gearbox is.

    I was talking about a shaft junction, but belgabor kindly pointed out that they can't be split.
     
  14. Turtles

    Turtles New Member

    I tested a lava smeltery from rotary craft with a 64x tile acelerator, pretty godly

    Enviado de meu XT1032 usando Tapatalk
     
    Pyure likes this.
  15. malicious_bloke

    malicious_bloke Over-Achiever

    Vanilla furnace
    Timelapse
    Declare victory.
     
    trajing likes this.
  16. Mevansuto

    Mevansuto New Member

    Is this even possible to measure? Considering you can have a smeltery that can smelt 738 blocks at a time (maximum presuming you start the layer above flat bedrock) and each ore smelts at different rates. Hmm. I really want to test this.
     
  17. belgabor

    belgabor New Member

    From the v24 changelog:
    • GeoStrata: Tile Accelerator no longer works on any machine from RC or its addons
     
    Turtles likes this.
  18. Mevansuto

    Mevansuto New Member

    Sigh. He adds a feature that greatly affects the balance other mods, but deems too OP for his own mod. I am assuming here. I'm assuming it's not because of a bug.
     
    Turtles likes this.
  19. rhn

    rhn Too Much Free Time

    Hmm people can say what they want about IC2(E), but that Induction Furnace is just a beast when comparing both items/t and power/item.
     
  20. Padfoote

    Padfoote Brick Thrower Team Member Forum Moderator

    From what I read over on his MCF thread, it's because of how his mods consume power versus how other mods handle it.
     

Share This Page