Hey SoraZodia
As always, I encourage you to withhold any obviously "valuable" information from me any anyone else. I (and anyone else) may be a wolf.
Did you tell your role to anyone last night? VikeStep in particular was polling people yesterday. Did you divulge your role to him?
If you divulged a buff role to someone, I'd be concerned you told your role to a wolf.
---
Greetings and such HeilMewTwo
You aren't willing to disclose your reasons for voting me on the main thread. Can you tell me why privately?
I'm guessing you're "bait", or somehow affected by an external ability.
If you're affected by an external ability that prevents you to disclose such, please don't reply at all.
Interesting. Thx.
Fwiw, I suspect somesone is "Gideon". If not, just fyi, Gideon is confirmed goodie.
Do we trust him for some reason? I don't.
---
I think its definitely worth keeping an eye on. Hrm.
---
huh.
That's pretty hard role-evidence to contradict.
I didn't realize we'd actually picked out someone lying. That's very interesting.
I'm inclined to vote HeilMewTwo based purely on that and for lack of anything better.
Holy crap, did my last comment start this landslide against Heilmewtwo?
---
Hey dood!
We're at a point of the game where I've gotta start asking ppl their roles. Will you divulge yours?
I'm a Villager. In the boring, old sense.
---
convo Pyure posted
---
I'm not super-100%-ready to disclose my role. I'm a villager, and not a wolf.
Good luck with the bait thing though.
Not in entirety. I have RJS with a couple of "suspicions" and eruantien with a couple of "negative suspicions".
At first glance, yes. I'm going through it in detail to confirm, gimme a sec.
Word for word looks legit.
[Redacted] is:
"Well to address your second point I actually am the mad warrior this time. Not sure how I can prove it except by using it and dieing."
Vike's entire thread looks suspicious as all fuck but I can't correlate Vike=Wolf with him a) not murdering me, and b) not murdering the spy.
HTH
Gideon?
Well that was a useful two-way exchange of information
Hmm. I don't like what this suggests about your motives.
What I mean is, if you think i'm a villager (and I think you do), why aren't you helping me filter out the other villagers?
For instance, I've started a minor lynch on RJS. But if you know he's inno, lemme know. (the fact that he was contacted by the spy does not make him innocent btw)
1. Ok thx. He proved he was the spy to me on N2, but I kept wondering if he had managed to "work the system" somehow
2. Who is more suspicious to you than RJS?
In all honesty, my notes aren't very useful. There's no team of wolves here, and 90% of my logic is based on wolf-cooperation flags.
If you have any specific questions, I'll tell you what I know.
To give you a rough idea: the highest suspicion level is currently 7/10 (RJS).
You have a 5.5/10 yourself, and you earned that 0.5 simply because you hadn't been active for a long time when the wolf "forgot" to murder someone. Evidence is shit in this game.
---
I like cheerios!
I assumed my Ralph Wiggum-esque reply would have made you say "Boy did I bet on the wrong horse."
Ok, since you're not to be deterred, I assume its a typo because its Cheese and he does that
If the next summary has a "7", I'll be more concerned. Nothing we can do about it tonight.
Woh, you have powers? I didn't know that, I just thought you were a villager like me.
Oh, right, totally.
Well, someone's gotta get lynched. I figure I should just keep doing my best to rate "most likely to be wolf", and if that means I die in the process, well, its a sacrifice I'm willing to make.
Its possible that a particularly vindictive person might decide to use a power in retribution, knowing it could cost his team a victory, but you understand I can't operate thinking someone would do that.
I actually put new guy as -1 suspicion for that very reason, but I'm also conscious that I publicized that theory before the game started and Cheese might want to turn the tables on me.
You planning to gun anybody down sir?
btw, I checked with god: I was concerned the mad warrior could bring down two suckers, but I think because of the order of operations (powers first, then lynches) you can't trigger your second-kill if you use your first (which kills you before you're lynched)
PS: Just to mess with the universe a bit, I'm about to ninja-switch my vote
---
Hey. I have you as "pretty darn innocent" since early game.
9. Eruantien (3/10) (nobody, xtordx->SkeletonPunk, SpwnX, HeilMewTwo, RJS) (recognized Vike as a threat but didn’t murder him: -1; late comms but didn’t wolfkill: -1)
(I realize some of that is gibberish to others, I'm too lazy to clean it up)
I'm a villager of the "literally a villager" sort. Can you disclose your role?
Is there any particular role you need to know about so you don't accidentally lynch him?
Did I already start a thread with you? :\ Damn I am terrible at keeping track, sorry.
I have no idea what role you're claiming.
I don't think coolsquid is really a wolf. I think he's an idiot or a genius (most likely the former)
I'll jot you down as another boring old villager for now (which is what I am)
I played the original Zelda like 20 years ago, I forget everything about it (Except that it was fun) Sorry :\
I wonder if there's a way for me to see your avatar history
Makes sense. I was actually *really* hoping you'd claim hero. SpwnX also claims hero, and with yoy1zoz2mom3 being confirmed hero, that makes 3 heroes (highly unlikely).
Here's my voting-trend notes on you:
9. Eruantien (3/10) (nobody, xtordx->SkeletonPunk, SpwnX, HeilMewTwo, RJS, coolsquid321) (recognized Vike as a threat but didn’t murder him: -1; late comms but didn’t wolfkill: -1)
Here's my notes on spanks:
4. SpwnX (5.5/10, Claims Hero) (nobody, SkeletonPunk, goreae, HeilMewTwo, RJS, coolsquid321) (No comms last 3 hours on no-murder day +.5; doesn’t know identity of spy +.5)
Mathematically I trust you more at this time. I'll probably be voting SpwnX and I'll be trying to convince others to do the same.
Don't I have 6? Oh, I just added the .5 for the spy thing this morning. He also deserves another +1 for claiming a role I don't believe.
Thx for correction.
fyi I already pretended I was bait to try to lure him out as a wolf-ally. He firmly claimed bachman. Don't pretend you're bait
I'll wait till I hear from you to vote.
I have no idea how the wolf thing is supposed to work. I won't be surprised if there are no wolves at all.
Here's my prediction: last man standing has shown himself to be a bloodthirsty dick and therefore is, himself, the final wolf.
Btw, why didn't you bandwagon on D3? You voted for spwnx and everyone else voted goreae.
If just a couple ppl vote for SpwnX, I can use my power to increase the vote tally if necessary.
---
Hey squid, good job on your first game man.
On a scale of 1->10, where 10 is "rather high", how much wolfiness would you say your role has?
If he hasn't already, Vikestep is going to contact you soon and try to manipulate you into this and that for his amusement. Fair warning.
If you're the wolf, just fyi, my victory condition doesn't require you to lose. I'm happy to help you win so long as I win too.
Man that's really high. My thought process is to consider lynching Vike today and let you murder me when everyone else is dead on the last day. You won't be able to eat anyone the next day, but who cares, the game's over.
Oh, I can help with that man.
Here's the scale:
God (Cheese) 10/10. Total wolf.
Wolf: 7/10
Mad Warrior: 6/10
Bait: 5/10
Absorber: 4/10
Gambler: 3/10
Hero: 2/10
Bachman: 1/10
Everything else: 0/10
I'm a 5. My own wolf-factor is pretty brutal as it is.
Hey
No fibbing.
You can't be a 1 because there's already too many of those (the_J and xtordX are both confirmed by god)
Honestly you know how to make a grown man weep at his desk. :`(
Something like this:
You are the bait!
If the wolf kills you, he or she will be unable to kill anyone the next day.
Victory condition(s): You cannot win alive. The villagers must win and you must be killed by the wolf in order for you to win.
I've retracted my vote for you. I'll see if I can find someone more suspicious to vote for.
Squid, if you show up in time, consider shifting your vote to spwnx. If 1 or 2 ppl vote for him, I can use my power to change the vote tally a bit and get him lynched instead of you.
---
Guys I think we need to work together a bit better here. I'm just going to up and share what I know and what I think. I've included you both because every other player has an inkling possibility of being a wolf.
- I have xTordX as a confirmed bachman, by virtue of word of god.
- I have Gideon as a more-or-less-confirmed Spy, by virtue of the fact he knows everyone's convos.
- Pyure is a "boring old villager." I am not in any way confirmed, I don't expect you to pretend that I am. Your balanced trust is appreciated.
Thoughts on people:
coolsquid321 (Claims bachman 5/10): annoying as fuck, but I think he's genuinely a bachman. I just spent 20 minutes interrogating him. I can't account for his goofing off claiming he's a wolf however. FYI: I pretended I was "bait" willing to work with him. I'll provide the convo in a moment to keep this one post from going too tl/dr.
Eruantien(Role?? 3/10): I have him as "unlikely to be wolf". He recognized Vike as a logical murder victim and didn't murder him. On the day the wolf forgot to murder anyone, Eruantien was still active late in the afternoon.
SpwnX (Claims Hero, 6/10): He has contributed virtually nothing to the game. He logs on to vote and goes away. On the day the wolf forgot to vote, SpwnX was absent for the 3 hours preceeding end of day.
Vikestep:
(Claims Mad Warrior, 6/10) Has contributed nothing besides inflammatory speeches. He disappeared for a long period (4-5 hours) when the wolf neglected to kill. This is actually in his favour: I can't imagine Vike neglecting to murder.
Pyure: (Claims boring old villager, 0/10) I don't keep notes on myself aside from my voting history.
8. Pyure (nobody, xtordx->skeletonpunk(lock), Goreae, {Forgot to note}, RJS->xTordX, coolsquid321->??)
I'm keeping myself in the list of "suspects" because it might be statistically relevant.
I'm leaning towards voting spanks at this time. For a couple reasons:
1) Vike would have killed me
2) Vike would have killed the spy
3) Vike wouldn't forget to murder someone
4) SpwnX doesn't (reliably) know who the spy is.
Pyure: On a scale of 1->10, where ten is "rather high", how much wolfiness would you say your role has?
If you are the wolf, just fyi, my victory condition doesn't require you to lose. I'm happy to help you win so long as I win too.
Squid: For wolfiness, 6/10 maybe.
Pyure: Wow that is really high. My thought process is to consider lynching Vike today and let you murder me when everyone else is dead on the last day. You won't be able to eat anyone the next day, but who cares, the game's over. Thoughts?
Squid: Oh, is 6 high? Then I am lower. Maybe a bit more wolfy than some other roles, but not a lot.
Pyure: I can help with that man. Here's the scale:
God (Cheese) 10/10. Total wolf.
Wolf: 7/10
Mad Warrior: 6/10
Bait: 5/10
Absorber: 4/10
Gambler: 3/10
Hero: 2/10
Bachman: 1/10
Everything else: 0/10
I am a 5. My own wolf-factor is pretty brutal as it is.
Squid: Oh then I'm a 1. I'm just behaving a bit wolfy
Pyure: Hey
No fibbing. You cannot be a 1 because there are already too many of those (the_J and xtordX are both confirmed by god) Honestly you know how to make a grown man weep at his desk.
Squid: at least *was* a bachman. Can an absorber have taken it?
Pyure: Maybe you should triple-check the role you got from cheese? He would not make three bachmans. You should have a convo from him telling you what your power is and what your victory condition is.
Squid: Believe what you want. He wrote that I am a bachman.
Pyure: Something like this?
You are the bait!
If the wolf kills you, he or she will be unable to kill anyone the next day.
Victory condition(s): You cannot win alive. The villagers must win and you must be killed by the wolf in order for you to win.
Squid: I cannot copy directly, but he wrote: (title: )You are the bachman! Win with the village.
Pyure: I've retracted my vote for you. I'll see if I can find someone more suspicious to vote for.
Squid: If I was the wolf, I would have stopped claiming being a bachman long ago.
New info: Eruantien says he's a hero. If we assume that Cheese would not make three heroes, that means either Eruantien or SpwnX is lying. I trust Eruantien in this case.
Info: I just analyzed SpwnX's voting pattern. It precisely follows a pattern for a Hero: e.g. he always bandwagons. Just fair disclosure.
Eruantien's pattern has an anomaly: he failed to bandwagon on D3, voting for spwnx instead of goreae (who was lynched). He also voted first that day.
Shrug for all I know we're all wolves and we just don't know it. The role I received from cheese is "boring old villager" and I'm working with that.
If just a couple ppl vote for SpwnX, I can use my power to increase the vote tally if necessary.
Hey tord, you became a forum member on my birthday, yay
If I'm dead today guys, definitely suspect SpwnX. A different wolf would leave me alive so that I could deflect a day's worth of voting to him.
xtord you were around to support my vote. Shame on you.
How are all these dead people claiming things?
I have really no good advice anymore. I suggest ppl do what they want
---
You're sort of proven as a villager. RJS isn't. So if you want me to talk about anything, I'll do it here.
I'm a "boring old villager."
Once in the game I may choose a person, and that person will get an extra vote that night. I must be alive to use this ability.
You're the only one I've confessed my role to.
Huh, good to know, thx. Too bad there were no obvious lies to work with.
Gid, how many people do NOT know you're a spy?
Would you consider your role to be powerful?
If I were a wolf and I knew your identity, you'd be dead by now.
Ok. I'm going to give only a tiny increase of suspicion to ppl who don't know your role. Personally, I find convos to be an important bad guy tool and I think you hamper that, but for someone like, say, SoraZodia, who plays quietly, they might just be content to sit there silently eating people every night.
Gideon, if I die soon: Keep a close eye on the "younger" players. In particular some on your list, such as Eruantien, xTordX, even coolsquid.
I find it odd that nobody has murdered me or vike. Vike in particular has a reputation. For that matter, if another "mad warrior" pops up in the nightly summary, kill Vike right away.
lol
Honestly I've 180'd since that comment. Now I have my eyes on RJS and StrikingWolf, neither of whom were active later in the day.
I can't imagine VikeStep would forget to wolf-kill, and I can sort of see him keeping me alive for fun so long as I wasn't a particular threat.
In descending order of suspicion at this time:
- RJS
- VikeStep
- StrikingWolf
- coolSquid321
- SpwnX
- xTordX
- Eruantien
- GideonSeymour
- LivingAngryCheese
- Pyure
The ordering of the last three is mostly "funny", but its technically and logically accurate.
I think I meant to flip Strike and Vike there.
No particular reason it isn't possible.
I have like zero good information here man. I feel like I'm shooting in the dark.
One wolf doesn't present enough intrigue to get info from.
Gideon, I may tell some fibs to Eruantien. I need to start trying to lure out the wolf, and if I can get him to divulge some major interest in, say, the spy, I might point him at someone like Vikestep.
I think that makes 3 bachmans. I don't buy it. Squid's gotta be wolf.
Gideon, if you wake up on time, help me lynch SpwnX plz. I'm basically asking everyone to assist with SpwnX today and then Vike tomorrow.
I expect to be murdered in 2 hours, at which point Vike will have free reign to make up whatever stories about elves and santa and roleblocking he pleases and history suggests people will eat it up.