Gotham a game of Mafia [Werewolf][Game Thread]

Discussion in 'Forum Games' started by dylanpiera, Jun 7, 2016.

  1. LivingAngryCheese

    LivingAngryCheese Over-Achiever

    nojr claimed straight away, leth just voted and waited for nojr to claim, then said he was lying. I still think it's leth.
  2. Lethosos

    Lethosos New Member

    Nah, wouldn't scum make the claim first, to make themselves look better?

    Sent from my Puzzle Box of Yogg-Saron using Tapatalk 2
  3. RealKC

    RealKC Popular Member

    I'll change my vote to Leth. I'm hoping that I'm doing the right thing...
    LivingAngryCheese likes this.
  4. Lethosos

    Lethosos New Member I'm wondering if Cheese might be scum, too.

    Sent from my Puzzle Box of Yogg-Saron using Tapatalk 2
  5. 016Nojr

    016Nojr Well-Known Member

    That would not be possible since we are 4 people left
    LivingAngryCheese likes this.
  6. 016Nojr

    016Nojr Well-Known Member

    @LivingAngryCheese lock?
  7. RealKC

    RealKC Popular Member

    Why did I got pinged again?
  8. LivingAngryCheese

    LivingAngryCheese Over-Achiever

    No idea. I guess I'll lock
  9. Lethosos

    Lethosos New Member

    I believe that you're making a terrible mistake, Cheese, but... What's done is done.

    Sent from my Puzzle Box of Yogg-Saron using Tapatalk 2
  10. LivingAngryCheese

    LivingAngryCheese Over-Achiever

  11. 016Nojr

    016Nojr Well-Known Member

    LivingAngryCheese likes this.
  12. LivingAngryCheese

    LivingAngryCheese Over-Achiever

    I'm getting the feeling that leth was innocent, so screw you
  13. dylanpiera

    dylanpiera New Member

    Excuse me for my lack of excistence yesterday, Day end. Recap in bit (can take a few hours)
  14. dylanpiera

    dylanpiera New Member

    Day 5 recap
    • Lethosos was lynched. He did not leave a note.
    And with that.

    The game has ended.

    • Shazam - Clayface
    • Vikestep - Bat Family
    • RealKC - Bat Family
    • Someone Else 37 - Bat Family
    • Strikingwolf - Bat Family
    • Nojr - Bat Family
    • Profrags - Bat Family
    • Livingangrycheese - Bat Family
    • Pyure - Ridler
    • Corpsecat - Mafia
    • Erindalc - Mafia
    • Lethosos - Mafia

    Game recap

    So first of all, let me go back to the signups,
    I should've listened. The game, It is cursed.

    All "Joking" aside, the game was pretty darn bad.

    The main reasons being:
    • Major Inactivity, both on player and my side.
    • Unbalanced game -- or should I say unbalancable.
    • Small player list
    This game was originally supposed to be an all out super brawl, which I changed to have less over powered characters, but in the progress. I made a few mistakes and definetly with the two neutral parties. The galery of rogues and the league of assasins.
    Not only that, but the combination of Pyure the Ridler dying D1 with nobody being active (Or remembering) to write a note for their death, the game was pretty screwed at the beginning.

    I have learned a few things from this game tho.
    • No role revelation on dead can be really bad and broken.
    • Never agree to take a sheet of of Shazam's hands.
    • Long signups are a killer
    • Big game, small audience? Either balance the game around them, or change up the game instead of waiting 2 weeks.
    I'm sorry for the inconvieniance ya'll. Next time if anyone agrees to take an abandoned sheet of of Shazam. Please stop them.

    small note: i'm not going to go into details of the mechanics of this game. They where just horrible.
    LivingAngryCheese likes this.
  15. 016Nojr

    016Nojr Well-Known Member

    What about now? I had a feeling you were the last one :p
    LivingAngryCheese likes this.
  16. Pyure

    Pyure Not Totally Useless

    Sorry I tossed my char right away. I really did just derp and fail to read the rolesheet.

    Wow nice job guys hitting the mafia w/ no role feedback on death, that's actually...really amazing. GG :)

    @dylanpiera: Good call on your game summary. I definitely agree, role revelation is a critical part of the game if you want people to actually TALK about stuff.
    LivingAngryCheese likes this.
  17. LivingAngryCheese

    LivingAngryCheese Over-Achiever

    Thank you, thank you
  18. Lethosos

    Lethosos New Member

    Not really, erin and corpse got smote by the Hand of the GM. I did try and confuse the Red Robin identity a fair bit, but you managed to grab the wrong stick and ran with it. You were my scumvote that night, though.

    Sent from my Puzzle Box of Yogg-Saron using Tapatalk 2
  19. profrags

    profrags Guest

    I only killed my team :3 I am definitely good at this game!
  20. LivingAngryCheese

    LivingAngryCheese Over-Achiever

    It was obvious it was you, let's be honest here. And the other two, that's their fault.
    profrags likes this.

Share This Page