[Game Thread] Fallen Angels 3 Werewolf

Discussion in 'Forum Games' started by erindalc, Jun 19, 2017.

  1. Pyure

    Pyure Not Totally Useless

    GWNG: The RP is fun, but try to chime in with actual discussion. I don't wanna read between the lines :)
    GamerwithnoGame likes this.
  2. Pyure

    Pyure Not Totally Useless

    I'm inclined to agree.
  3. GamerwithnoGame

    GamerwithnoGame Forum Addict

    Apologies, I'm getting a bit too into the "whodunnit" aspect I think! I was going to wait and see more of the discussion before I chipped in again with a vote, as I'm still getting used to trying to read what's going on myself. Its hard! Thanks for bearing with me though
  4. RJS

    RJS Popular Member

    As a quick little TL;DR: Nojr votes Pyure, Pyure requests some reasoning, Nojr deflects immediately onto me. I may be a bit biased here, but that strikes me as being a bit suspicious to say the least.

    However, we had no wolf kill. Flagging up Monster is one thing, but what about triggerfinger? He literally hasn't even posted yet.

    Also, if I sound off, it may be because I have not yet had more than 5.5hrs of sleep any night this week, and my being 'quiet' is called waking up at 7, leaving for work at 7.30 and not getting back until about 20 mins ago. Any questions?
  5. erindalc

    erindalc Popular Member

    Rule clarification: If the Blacksmith saves someone successfully, the person who was saved is informed. Rolesheet has been updated.
  6. Pyure

    Pyure Not Totally Useless

    Anyone in particular seem less or more bad-ish to you?

    I'm going to go with vote triggerfinger. I hate to go with the no-kill-equals-lynch-absentees thing, especially if a silly wolf thinks it pays off to do that, but its the strongest argument currently.

    I'm also not a big fan of Nojr
    I'm not super excited about GWNG
    I'm very neutral on RJS
    I'm leaning positive on the_J

    Other people need to contribute a bit more.
  7. RJS

    RJS Popular Member

    I'm going to have to lean on Nojr to be honest. I don't like his activity today, and it is always worth remembering that we have blacksmiths. Besides, if trigger doesn't post before day end he dies anyway and so we waste the lynch.

    Vote Nojr
  8. GamerwithnoGame

    GamerwithnoGame Forum Addict

    Ok, I'm going to try and keep it RP-light, analysis-heavy (or at least less light):

    Picking up on @RJS's comment, and knowing for myself that sometimes RL makes these things more challenging than you'd hope, I want to give Trig a pass. Because I'm not so familiar with the absentee thing, I'm not sure I get where you're coming from.

    Likewise, I feel for @RJS himself, his response seems borne of of genuine frustration rather than trying to cover anything.

    Looking at what you've said about Nojr... there is something.

    Yep... Vote 016Nojr

    You and my wife both, mate.
  9. erindalc

    erindalc Popular Member

    ( ⚆ _ ⚆ )
    GamerwithnoGame likes this.
  10. GamerwithnoGame

    GamerwithnoGame Forum Addict

    British self-deprecating humour.

    It's what we do.
    fowltief and erindalc like this.
  11. the_j485

    the_j485 King of the Wicked

    Oh please, we're usually better than that :p

    I'm honestly leaning to vote Nojr with this one. The evidence against him seems to be the strongest.
  12. MrMonsterGuy18

    MrMonsterGuy18 Well-Known Member

    Trigger wasn't here yesterday, and, if his was a wolf, couldn't kill anyone. The people below him were Gamer and 016Nojr. 016 set up Pyure as today's scapegoat yesterday, who, if Trigger is an angel, is a villager. So 016 is either a wolf or a villager acting angelic.

    Vote 016Nojr
    Pyure likes this.
  13. fowltief

    fowltief Well-Known Member

    Logically a wolf would be more active. There are very few instances of past games I can think of when a wolf went AWOL.
    Given the lack of info we have to work with....

    Vote nojr

    Sent from my 0PJA2 using Tapatalk
  14. erindalc

    erindalc Popular Member

    Day 2 has ended!

    Recap incoming!
  15. erindalc

    erindalc Popular Member

    triggerfinger12 was smitten! He was the Hunter!

    RJS was killed by the Judicator! He was the Blacksmith (oops)!

    016nojr was lynched! He was a Farmer!

    Day 3 has begun! You may post!
    Last edited: Jun 22, 2017
  16. MrMonsterGuy18

    MrMonsterGuy18 Well-Known Member

    Pyure s been leading the angelhunt to villagers, and if he is an angel, then he knows the other angel.

    Vote Pyure
  17. erindalc

    erindalc Popular Member

    Your GM is very stupid and needs to read his words more closely.

    RJS was the Blacksmith, not a Farmer.

    Sent from my VS835 using Tapatalk
  18. Pyure

    Pyure Not Totally Useless

    From your tone, I'm guessing that makes you our angel.

    Also, you're fibbing. I led the lynch on N1.

    Also, you joined the dogpile on Nojr.

    Also, you were reeeeaally excited to join the lynch on N1.

    Also: RJS snooped me with ethereal light N1 and cleared me as non-angel.

    Also: @erindalc, has the light changed hands? SHould we be notified of that?
  19. GamerwithnoGame

    GamerwithnoGame Forum Addict

    My instincts on RJS were dead right, and my instincts on Nojr were dead wrong. Brilliant. Though to be fair, my negative impressions on Nojr were less strong than my positive ones on RJS. Which isn't helpful.

    I'm not sure I follow Monster's reasoning; maybe Pyure is bluffing, but claiming clearing from RJS when it can't be backed up is such a bare-faced statement, it would take some balls for it to be a lie! And from the get-go, Pyure - while having some fairly twisty-turny reasoning - has been very open. From what little instincts I've managed to build up, I'm getting nothing but the feeling that he really is what he says he is.

    the_j has been quiet, but (and I apologise if this is a bit meta-gaming) if I'm right that he's a Brit, that's probably a work/school thing, and I think we'll hear from him.

    Likewise fowl... I haven't seen enough from him to get a feel, and he's been awfully quiet as well. But that seems more like wariness and looking for suspicious signs.

    But I'll be damned if your reasoning for Monster isn't compelling... right now I'm at vote Monster.
  20. Pyure

    Pyure Not Totally Useless

    Its a bit shady, but i'm half hoping the GM will confirm the ethereal light moved on last night, which will support my RJS comment.
    erindalc likes this.

Share This Page