The modding community has been split into two so many times already.
Forge and Nova
- Thread starter Strikingwolf
- Start date
-
The FTB Forum is now read-only, and is here as an archive. To participate in our community discussions, please join our Discord! https://ftb.team/discord
Well, that alternate mod loader's Java 8 requirement spawned off this whole drama fight.
Lex is a very capable coder, he just needs to learn how to control his emotions in public.
screaming and threatening around like that helps no one, it rather only creates more problems.
screaming and threatening around like that helps no one, it rather only creates more problems.
honestly, unless it is absolutely terrible, i don't mind some version of something being required, as long as the default download for that thing meets the requirement.(currently, if you go to get java, it gives 8 by default so i don't care )
also, i like how in the beginning 1.7 was this evil monster version that performed horribly and basically ate kittens, and now we want to stay there.(it just seems funny to me)
)also, i like how in the beginning 1.7 was this evil monster version that performed horribly and basically ate kittens, and now we want to stay there.(it just seems funny to me
)I guess the 1.8 case is worse, due to the rendering stuff, and the BlockState and BlockPos are not just annoying to code with but also take up more RAM and more garbage collector timealso, i like how in the beginning 1.7 was this evil monster version that performed horribly and basically ate kittens, and now we want to stay there.(it just seems funny to me
honestly, unless it is absolutely terrible, i don't mind some version of something being required, as long as the default download for that thing meets the requirement.(currently, if you go to get java, it gives 8 by default so i don't care
also, i like how in the beginning 1.7 was this evil monster version that performed horribly and basically ate kittens, and now we want to stay there.(it just seems funny to me
No one ever likes updating. The mod devs don't like the work and players don't like that some mods inevitably get lost along the way.
Celestialphoenix
Too Much Free Time
"Asshole dictator of the Minecraft Modding community"
At least he's honest.
Well now we've collectively tamed that monster is isn't so bad- the amount of work it took to get this far, and we're told 'do it all again for 1.8'
And kittens taste nice.
At least he's honest.
Well now we've collectively tamed that monster is isn't so bad- the amount of work it took to get this far, and we're told 'do it all again for 1.8'
And kittens taste nice.
Attachments
Lex is the developer of Forge; the only way to replace him is to move to a fork.
It could be added to Minecraft Forkage, or another fork (although I don't know of any) - Minecraft Forkage is my intended long-term-support version of 1.7.10 Forge, based on the deeply introspective philosophy of "1.8 sucks". Unfortunately it's just getting started (and so doesn't have things set up yet e.g. no pre-build binaries; there will be a forum soon), and nowhere near critical mass. Ask me about a PR tomorrow, or if it's simple enough I can just add it myself.
The problem with adding features to forks willy-nilly is that nobody actually uses your fork. Therefore, if your mod depends on the fork, nobody can use your mod - especially the big modpack makers who you really want to use it.
If forking Forge is the answer, then we need lots of people to support one fork.
Celestialphoenix
Too Much Free Time
Forge has changed devs before. Its perfectly reasonable to say it can happen again.
But certainly a 7.10 fork would be a good idea. (heck- it might even get the ball rolling with a bit of good luck)
But certainly a 7.10 fork would be a good idea. (heck- it might even get the ball rolling with a bit of good luck)
Dylan Miller@dylanstweetsThere's also this:
https://luacs1998.wordpress.com/2015/02/01/arigatou-sayonara/
https://luacs1998.wordpress.com/2015/02/01/arigatou-sayonara/
Modding might actually die out at this rate, we have been losing so many since Microsoft took over and a bunch quit as a result and cpw doing the same thing did not help.
" However, it seems that in light of recent events, His Majesty the Emperor LexManos has seen fit to remove me from his court."
Sounds like something from a fantasy novel.
Sounds like something from a fantasy novel.
Celestialphoenix
Too Much Free Time
Modding won't die out.
It'll evolve and change- today's dinosaurs will be extinct in tomorrows world, but there will still be life.
It'll evolve and change- today's dinosaurs will be extinct in tomorrows world, but there will still be life.