Where do i put suggestions

[halander1]

Hey guys, so i was thinking that it would be cool to suggest a certain mod to the infinity modpack, but i don't know where to put the suggestion.

p.s. (Yes i do realize i can just locally add it, thank you.)

 

[Padfoote]

AFAIK the team is not taking mod suggestions.

 

[halander1]

Alright, thanks.

 

[Azzanine]

Plus people tend to just ignorantly suggest any mod without first considering why the mods aren't already in a pack.
Most people glance over distribution permission; Like all the players suggesting FTB have "Better then Wolves" or "Mo'Creatures" Both mods authors prohibit or restrict redistribution for their own reasons.
Also mods like Optifine not only have the same permission problem but has compatibility issues with mods anyway.
Then there's the case of mod pack balance and redundancy.

That being said, while FTB are not officially takeing suggestions they would have to be incredibly ignorant and moronic to pass over a decent well thought out suggestion. If you see a good mod that would fit in with a pack you could always make a new thread to discuss it. If someone in the FTB team is keeping their finger on the modding scenes pulse they will know about the mods casueing buzz.

 

[rhn]

The reason threads like this get locked is because they don't serve a purpose and just serve to agitate well-meaning people. By the time a pack is publicly announced the mod lists are pretty well nailed down; basically, unless a pack author/coordinator is specifically requesting suggestions for additions, it's not going to happen.

The reasons are manifold:

• A lot of work goes into these packs pre-release that can get thrown out of whack by arbitrary last second additions. The pack development process isn't "throw together a list of mods and slap a name on it", and decisions on the list have already been made with criteria in mind.
• If they add what you want, why won't they add what player X and player Y and player Z want? Where does it end? At that point Infinity becomes a description of the system requirements of the pack, if all these suggestions were taken.
• On the subject of LPs and the like, it can be seriously disruptive to just throw in mods willy-nilly in the midst of a world like that. Changes to the mod list tend to reflect either minor tweaks or the addition of awaited content (e.g. Thermal Dynamics wasn't out at the initial release, but it has always been intended to be included so when it was released it was added).
• On the subject of Ars Magica 2 itself, that mod represents about the most problematic kind of mod to add to a pack in progress that there is. It has content across the spectrum and all kinds of places for interaction to go awry. Remember, folks, when you add a mod to a pack, it isn't just about what it brings, but what it does to the rest of the mods already in the pack. The larger the pack, the more exponential the amount of cross-checking gets. Even more so when you have a content-spanning mod like Ars that touches on pretty much every system in Minecraft with something.

With that all said (and that's not even all to say, but at this point it's more than enough), there's no room to go back-and-forth on this, because unless the people in charge of the pack want something, it isn't getting in there, and we don't encourage badgering for content by humoring these threads because, as mentioned, they never end well. The pack team reads the forums and, who knows, maybe the stars align and they do decide to make the addition; however, more threads like this aren't going to be the determining factor on that.

http://forum.feed-the-beast.com/threads/request-for-infinity-pack.70719/#post-1003443

 

[Hambeau]

With a straight line like this thread title I'm having a difficult time with my "Dr. Donkey" side

 

[halander1]

Alright guys, thanks for the advice, I will heed it.