[GAME THREAD] WeRewolPh!

[sgbros1]

Midday vote recap!

Cheese (3) - Dylan, Pyure, Leth
Pyure (2) - HMT, Spwn
Epic (1) - Eru
Trajing (1)- Epic
Pizza (1) - Cheese
HMT (1) - Pizza
SE37 (1) - Trajing

Not voted yet: @ljfa, @VikeStep, @SoraZodia, @Exedra, @Shazam08, @016Nojr, @Someone Else 37

Okay, I'm going to set up an alarm for me to vote every morning.


I have not been PMed by Cheese, FYI.

Antismite Someone Else 37

I'd love to hear the reasoning behind the limited antismite rule - I really don't know why it would be useful.

It's to prevent antismite rounds. I just don't like them.

 

[Someone Else 37]

Speculation, but if I were Tzet, I'd reach out to that wolf and get them to help kill Shadia. I know it says that he technically sides with village, but the win condition kind of makes that irrelevant.

Except Shadia doesn't exist yet, and if/when she comes into existence (when Agartha dies), she'll side with the wolves.

Wait, @sgbros1, when you say that Tzet and Shadia side with the village/wolves, what does that actually mean? Can Tzet win if Shadia dies, but the wolves otherwise win?

 

[sgbros1]

Tzet, if Shadia does not exist, wins with the village. If Shadia exists, Tzet wins by killing Shadia (or at least with Shadia being dead).

 

[Pyure]

I hate ww-ing from my phone. I see I'm still not in line for my usual pyure-hate-thon yet, awesome. Going to bed. Sorry if I get lynched anyway guys.

 

[VikeStep]

Why in the world is cheese in line to be lynched? He's the least suspicious of any of us after he publicly claimed his role.

Lynch Lethosos for putting another vote on cheese.

 

[Someone Else 37]

Vike has a point... then again, I'm sure he's well aware that truthfully claiming a useless village role in public is a poor strategic decision, as it would lead the wolves away from you and toward more powerful village roles. By that logic, if Cheese is perfectly rational (which, granted, is unlikely, given the RP stuff), he'd be more likely to be a power village role or a wolf.

So why is Vike defending Cheese? If Cheese and Vike are both wolves, that'd make some sense, but would also put Vike up for lynch next if Cheese dies, which doesn't seem like something Vike would do. If Vike is a villager and truthfully believes that Cheese is also a villager, his actions would make more sense.

So... hmm. Vote Dylan for jumping on Cheese and because I don't want to antismite.

 

[Exedra]

Well I fractured my wrist so cyall later

 

[016Nojr]

anti-smite ljfa

 

[VikeStep]

I'm confused about why Pyure liked my post despite the fact he contributed to the problem I addressed...

 

[VikeStep]

Vike has a point... then again, I'm sure he's well aware that truthfully claiming a useless village role in public is a poor strategic decision, as it would lead the wolves away from you and toward more powerful village roles. By that logic, if Cheese is perfectly rational (which, granted, is unlikely, given the RP stuff), he'd be more likely to be a power village role or a wolf.

So why is Vike defending Cheese? If Cheese and Vike are both wolves, that'd make some sense, but would also put Vike up for lynch next if Cheese dies, which doesn't seem like something Vike would do. If Vike is a villager and truthfully believes that Cheese is also a villager, his actions would make more sense.

So... hmm. Vote Dylan for jumping on Cheese and because I don't want to antismite.

Also, what does voting Dylan accomplish? The point of voting leth was to get more votes on him than cheese has on himself. Dylan was also the first person to vote cheese and it was an antismite for all intents and purposes. Also I gave Pyure a break because of his computer issues. Thus my main suspicion lies with Leth.

 

[016Nojr]

@sgbros1 My anti-smite only gets used if it's my "final vote decision" right?

 

[LivingAngryCheese]

For god's sake guys does no one read the posts?
I am a confirmed villager.
Sg acknowledged that everything I said was true. He literally said that the banter about relationships was all true, which directly led on from the rest of it. I can go public with a useless role, because then the wolves don't want me dead.

 

[LivingAngryCheese]

Vote leth

 

[SoraZodia]

Vote Lethosos, not sure what your plans were but voting for a confirmed villager was really suspicious.

 

[LivingAngryCheese]

The only reason I haven't demanded everyone's roles is because I feel like that ruins the game, you could easily tell everyone to say their role at the start of the game and then lynch the duplicates... it just breaks the game.

 

[dylanpiera]

The only reason I haven't demanded everyone's roles is because I feel like that ruins the game, you could easily tell everyone to say their role at the start of the game and then lynch the duplicates... it just breaks the game.

In my opinion. Proving to everyone with your role convo that your an useless role. So you won't be killed. Is also breaking the game. You just make sure you won't be killed and then play along like everyone else. But unfair huh?

My opinion anyways.

So who are we lynching. Cause im confused who to vote for.

And about the rule @sgbros1
If everyone just votes someone else without saying anitsmite. You still have an antismite round.
The only way to not have them. Is to have someone tell them. And when all the players who understand this concept are either dead or a wolf (or sided with)
Then you get a game with only anti smites and an easy win for the wolfs.

 

[LivingAngryCheese]

In my opinion. Proving to everyone with your role convo that your an useless role. So you won't be killed. Is also breaking the game. You just make sure you won't be killed and then play along like everyone else. But unfair huh?

My opinion anyways.

So who are we lynching. Cause im confused who to vote for.

And about the rule @sgbros1
If everyone just votes someone else without saying anitsmite. You still have an antismite round.
The only way to not have them. Is to have someone tell them. And when all the players who understand this concept are either dead or a wolf (or sided with)
Then you get a game with only anti smites and an easy win for the wolfs.

Being proven as a villager is useful whether or not I use it to request everyone's roles.

 

[dylanpiera]

Being proven as a villager is useful whether or not I use it to request everyone's roles.

I DON'T HAVE TIME FOR ARGUE WAR AGAIN XD

Just saying my opinion.

 

[LivingAngryCheese]

Anyway we're voting for leth because he voted for me when I already had two antismites on me even though I'm a proven villager.

 

[ljfa]

I don't know how credible Cheese's claim is, quoting the role convo or faking it is a dirty trick in any case.
Well, I'm going to vote Vike. It's not unreasonable that they're both wolves.